Furnace |
Main
advantages |
Energy
used (kWh/lb) |
Metal
loss dross |
Energy
efficiency |
Main
complaints |
Remedy |
Indirect
fixed crucible |
- simple
- low
cost of capital equipment
- easy
to maintain
- gas
is cheap
|
3,300
BTU/lb (0.9969 kWh/lb) |
~3-8% |
13% |
- Low
pot life
- High
energy loss
- Emissions
- Noise
|
- Leave
a heel
- No
remedy
- No
remedy
- No
remedy
|
Direct
fixed (open flame) |
- very
simple
- low
cost
- easy
to maintain
- gas
is cheap
|
4,000
BTU/lb (1.172 kWh/lb) |
~5-12% |
11% |
- Low
pot life
- Very
high energy loss
- High
uncontrolled emission
- Very
high noise
|
- Leave
a heel
- No
remedy
- No
remedy
- No
remedy
|
Sloping
dry hearth |
none |
3,000-5,000
BTU/lb (0.879-1.465 kWh/lb) |
~5-12% |
9-15% |
- Noise
- Very
high melt loss
- High
energy loss
- Emissions
|
- Improve
flame impingement
- Charge
better scrap
- No
remedy
|
Wet
bath reverboratory |
none |
3,000
BTU/lb (0.879 kWh/lb) |
3-5% |
15% |
- High
energy loss
- Emissions/flue
|
|
Electric
radiant reverboratory |
- cold
start possible
- no
flue
- no
agitation
- no
noise
|
820
BTU/lb (0.2403 kWh/lb) |
1-3% |
54% |
- Very
high currents
- Very
small sizes
- High
cost of electricity
- Pot
life suspect if one element burns
|
- No
remedy
- Three
base
- No
remedy
- Constant
monitoring
|
Electric
induction channel type |
- rapid
melting
- cold
start possible
|
0.29
kWh/lb |
High |
45% |
- Too
much of mixing of dross
- Very
expensive equipment & large space
- Only
for holding furnace
- Non-metallics
in channels
- High
dross
- Electromagnetic
field
- Noise
|
- Use
only when holding furnace needed
|
Coreless
induction melting |
- rapid
melting
- cold
start possible
|
0.29
kWh/lb |
High |
45% |
- Very
expensive equipment
- High
dross
- Electromagnetic
field
- Noise
- Large
space needed
|
- Use
fluxing covering salts extensively
|
Plasma
Airtorch™ Cover
(Ionizer) |
- extremely
rapid melting
- highly
energy efficient
- excellent
for ingot, sprue and scrap melting
- least
iron contamination with sprue melting
- no
chemistry adjustment since Zn, Mg, Li will
not have time to vaporize
- no
noise
- no
emissions
- less
space
|
0.2
kWh/lb |
Insignificantly
low, < 1%. |
65% |
|
|